Worth a buy?

Discussion in 'Kung Fu' started by TonyMc, Jul 23, 2011.

  1. TonyMc

    TonyMc Valued Member

    Anyone ever read this book?

    Choy Li Fut Kung - Fu: by Doc-Fai Wong

    Is it any good?
     
  2. Ben Gash CLF

    Ben Gash CLF Valued Member

    It's quite old, and some of the information in it has been superceded. It used to be really cheap (about £7), and then I used to recommend it, but now that you can't seem to get it for under £13 I tend not to. On the flip side the publisher recently went under, so it'll become quite rare soon.
    The historical info is all available here http://plumblossom.net/ChoyLiFut/history.html
    and the technical info is all available here (and then some) http://www.youtube.com/user/HungSingMA
     
  3. TonyMc

    TonyMc Valued Member

    There was a copy on fleabay that was signed by the man himself. It was the content rather than the signature I was interested in. I will have a look at these links.

    Thanks for that..
     
  4. Mushroom

    Mushroom De-powered to come back better than before.

    Man, I know that feeling. Like my copy of Pak Mei 9 Step Push by HB Un bought it off Austin Goh funnily enough years ago when he had a store in London for about £5.
    Now its so rare I keep seeing it sold off for 10x the price! Lost it somewhere in the midst of my comics...
     
  5. TonyMc

    TonyMc Valued Member

    I remember that store, down Carnaby Street right?
     
  6. Mushroom

    Mushroom De-powered to come back better than before.

    Yup! Its now a Joe's coffee shop. Damn hippies!
     
  7. TonyMc

    TonyMc Valued Member

    I was in there nosing around one day and a girl walked in a bit tearful saying that 2 idiots were pestering her outside and could he (Austin Goh) help as they wouldn't go away. He asked her to point them out before telling her to wait there while he went to, as he put it, sort the w*anklers(his pronounciation) out. I was p*ssing myself laughing, he was a quite a funny guy.

    I looked to see that he had one in knots while giving the riot act to the other. They soon cleared off, I'll never forget that.
     
    Last edited: Jul 24, 2011
  8. Infrazael

    Infrazael Banned Banned

    If you live near Mushroom why not check out his school?

    That is if I'm not mistaken, you are still looking for a training hall.
     
  9. Yohan

    Yohan In the Spirit of Yohan Supporter

    Doc Fai Wong CLF has lots of forms. Hundreds of them. Forms with a Chinese Flute. Which should tell you about the style.

    If you want to learn to twirl a flute you should definitely buy this book.
     
  10. Ben Gash CLF

    Ben Gash CLF Valued Member

    Flute form's not in it........;) (also no twirling in the flute form, it's a pretty standard single stick).
    Yohan, I appreciate that you have the zeal of a convert, but not everyone's Kung Fu experiences are the same as yours, and not everyone has found modern functional training methods incompatible with their Kung Fu.
    I teach within the Plum Blossom federation, forms take up maybe 20% of my lesson time.
     
  11. Chimpcheng

    Chimpcheng Yup... Giant cow head... Supporter

    I had this book ages ago, it's mostly in bits lying some place in Newcastle. It's an interest read but not hugely useful. The most interesting bit was the list if forms in the back. I seem to recall elephant form in there and, as a kid, my mind exploded when I learnt CLF had horse bench (everyone's face movie Kung Fu weapon).

    If you can find it, grab it, but treat it more as a curiosity than a manual for how to smack people...
     
  12. Yohan

    Yohan In the Spirit of Yohan Supporter

    I know . . . I'm sorry for being so negative about it.
     
  13. Ben Gash CLF

    Ben Gash CLF Valued Member

    There's a fuller forms list here
    http://plumblossom.net/ChoyLiFut/formslist.html
     
  14. Chimpcheng

    Chimpcheng Yup... Giant cow head... Supporter

    Ah ha! I see elephant form is in there! I was starting to think I made it up... :)
     
  15. Ben Gash CLF

    Ben Gash CLF Valued Member

    Jo at Guan Yin in Norwich knows it, I've not seen it though.
     
  16. Chimpcheng

    Chimpcheng Yup... Giant cow head... Supporter

    I'm not such a big follower of forms these days, they have their uses, but I hate when forms are taught just for the sake of it and without application. It took MMA classes for me to work out what some of the more "exotic" CLF techniques were for...
     
  17. TonyMc

    TonyMc Valued Member

    I've had a look at the site, which I found very interesting. However my attention was particularly drawn to this;

    I Fought Six Pocket Picking Gangsters in Guangzhou!


    By
    Gm Doc-Fai Wong
    中 文 按 此





    Recently I visited Guangzhou China. On November 24, 2008, around 4 PM, by the bus station of Zhongshan 8th Road . I unexpectedly wound up in a savage fight to protect myself from a gang of violent pickpockets!

    In this area there is a local outdoor market with lots of stalls selling fresh fruits, produce, clothing, shoes, food and so on. I was browsing in the market, when a guy walked next to me and bumped into my left side. At the same time, another man was trying to pick my pocket on my right. I felt my pocket moving and realized I was being robbed! I turned around and threw a back fist into the face of the thief ending the robbery. But much to my surprise another crook immediately moved in to help his friend. He approached from the front on my right side and tried to attack me. I used the same hand, my right, to hit this new attacker with a swinging fist to the back of his head. Yet another criminal on my left side rushed over and tried to attack me! In the blink of an eye I found myself in a serious fight with multiple street toughs!

    I used a side kick thrust to the new attacker's hip. At the same time, I used the whipping fist to hit one of the other thieves who had moved back in to attack. As I was hitting my assailants, I was able to maneuver to one of the selling stalls to cover my back and prevent an attack from behind. In that split second, another angry thug rushed in. Without thinking I connected with a potent palm thrust to his nose. Two more attackers appeared out of nowhere and I met each with a rapid right fist to the face.

    Incredibly, I used my right hand to hit five attackers and kicked one of the others. I had instinctively prevailed in a unexpected fight against 6 street thugs! The crowd around me broke into spontaneous applause and cheering. One of the criminals was on the ground knocked out. Looking around I could see these guys were bleeding and in pain. They were hurting pretty badly and were understandably afraid of me. They wisely decided not to attack me anymore. However, I was still outnumbered 6 to one and I wanted to avoid Chinese Police complications, so I decided to retreat while I was ahead. The knuckles of my right hand were hurting quite a bit at that point but otherwise I wasn't injured. That next day my right arm was sore and tired. The entire fight with those 6 thugs, not including the pick pocket, was over in less than 10 seconds!

    After the fighting stopped, I thought through what had just happened. I realized that I only used my right hand for all the strikes. The first strike was a kwa-chui that hit the guy who tried to pick my pocket. I used the kup-chui to hit the first thug who rushed in to try and help the robber. Then I followed up with a left tsang-geuk kick to the 2nd attacker and I lashed out with a dot-chui to the 3rd crook's neck. I used a gong-jeung thrust to the 4th hoodlum's nose and then used a tsop-chui to the 5th goon's face. With the same fist, I used another tsop to the 6th tough guy's eye.

    Everything rushed by in just a few seconds. Before I left the scene I surveyed the damage. One thief was knocked out cold on the ground. Some members of the gang tried to help him to wake up. I believe he was the thug I used the kup-chui on. Another one of the gang got up slowly from the ground obviously in pain. I had sent a couple of these bullies flying giving them bloody noses. Two other crooks ended up with blood on their mouths and chins.

    When I left the scene of the attack I was afraid that I might have seriously injured or killed the thug on the ground. I felt really bad about this, I do not like to hurt people. Happily, a couple days later, one of my students went back to the market area and asked a vendor who witnessed the fight what had happened to the knocked out gangster. A lady told him that the attacker on the ground was okay. He woke up and his gang helped him walk away. After this news, I felt much better. Hopefully, these crooks will think twice before preying on innocent victims in the future.

    I recounted the details of the fight to some of my students for learning and training experience. One student asked me why I only used my right hand. I landed blows with just my right because I am a right handed person, therefore my natural reaction was to use my right hand. I used my left hand as the guarding hand. A tai chi student asked me why I didn't use any of the tai chi fighting techniques. My answer was; I used the tai chi principles of fighting. In the tai chi classics, there is a saying: "When he is not moving, I don't move; when he moves, I get in first". The fact that I was able to walk away from this fight with only minor injuries was from my tai chi push hands timing and drilling training.

    I was able to respond instantly because of my years of reflex training from choy li fut. Another student asked me why I didn't just block the attackers' coming strikes; why had I decided to hit them? Here is how I answered the question: the saying in choy li fut is: "blocking without striking is a low level of fighting, blocking with striking is the intermediate level of fighting, striking without blocking is the high level of fighting". I don't think I am in that high level at all, but I applied the last principle to that situation at that time.

    It is important to remember that I struck the attackers only because they attacked me first. I have always said that the best fight is the one you never have. However, I train my students to know that when one must fight, then fight to win. This was one of those rare situations where there were no opportunities to withdraw peacefully. I had to fight, so I fought with everything I had. When I realized I was safe, I stopped and did not inflict unnecessary injury to my attackers. My job was to protect myself, the punishment of these criminals is the duty of higher forces in the Universe.


    I don't mean to sound disrespectful but I have always been sceptical of stories such as these. Is this Grandmaster really that good?
     
  18. Chimpcheng

    Chimpcheng Yup... Giant cow head... Supporter

    I'm impressed with the clarity at which the fight was recalled. My last fight, I threw punches, not sure what, they threw punches, I hit something, they hit me, end...
     
  19. TonyMc

    TonyMc Valued Member

    Very impressive for a 60 year old man, as he would of been at the time.
     
  20. Chimpcheng

    Chimpcheng Yup... Giant cow head... Supporter

    Doc Fai Wong is one of those figures in the CLF world that is adored by many but also despised by many too.

    I was at the CLF museum in Fo Shan back in 2007 and overheard a group of CLF Si Fu's slag off Doc Fai Wong (his skills, his schools, his students) as they peeked over his donations to the place. They claimed he was "bad" for CLF... These were also the same Si Fu's who's students were worse than bad when it came to martial skill.

    I have no particular feelings toward him either way, but, he, in no small way, helped increase the popularity of CLF.
     

Share This Page