Average male vs elite female judoka

How practical is judo in a fight? Who would win in a real fight, an average man (5'8/155) who have been recreational training in kickboxing for 6 months or an elite fat female judoka (5'8/200)?
Thanks for responses.

 

The elite fighter will win, 90% of the time.

Literally your giving up size, skills, and experience, however you are male, so........ It will hurt your ego more when you lose?

 

My god, what I really want to know is who would win: Elric with his sword Stormbringer, or Darth Vader??

 

This is a very specific scenario. I think the questions already been answered, but with all the other specifics you didn't add age. How old is the 5'8 200 female, and why is it that you want to fight her?

 

Not to be a dick but she probably is going to be fat in the heavyweights size helps, any size muscle or fat doesn't matter, case in point
Olympics: Sone claims women's heavyweight judo gold for Japan

 

So the point, judo is still effective for a real fight even the judoka is female and (maybe looks) fat? Many of them looks feminim so.

How about striking skill of the male, could the judoka defense from striking?

 

I'm beginner in martial arts so please go easy on me in this discussion . I just wonder how judo practical in real fight. I like watching judo match and want training but there are no judo club in my city (I live in south east Asia).

 

Judo is very practical as is kickboxing. The question is, what can you get to and have time to practice?

There are many different grappling styles also effective, so if there is no Judo you can possibly find another style. Which city or region are it looking to train?

 

What?! Out of context, Sir. just answer yes or no, simple as that. I'm sorry if you don't mind.

 

Thanks Sir. My country is different from European or American or other country which are many club/dojo. Martial arts I found just are muay thai, kickboxing and silat. There are bjj and judo gym in jakarta but it's so far (2 hours from my city).

Maybe I'll visit judo gym in European (Russia, Germany, etc) when I have holiday. Now I just train kickboxing recreationally 2 session per weeks.

Btw, I'm sure that profesional striking fighter will destroy untrained/beginner person but what about wrestling/judo/sambo? I don't know because I've never train and just watch that in YouTube

Honestly, before I posted this thread I've discussed about judo with my friend but I couldn't believe that judo is effective especially if the judoka is woman.

 

But If you don't like the 'woman' word, you can answer about 'judo' only and forget the 'woman' word, right?

 

It's more than carrying a bit of flab, and has nothing to do with being or not being strong, it's simply in a weight class with no upper limit being bigger than your opponent makes tactical sense.

And in a sport which isn't terribly aerobic how you get that size, muscle or fat isn't as important as getting that size

 

So you are basically asking if you had two people the same height, one of which outweighed the other by 50 pounds and was an elite athlete would would win in a fight?

Can't you see how silly that question is, about as silly as it was when first asked on the internet a few years ago