Martial Arts Planet



Go Back   Martial Arts Planet » Articles and Reviews » Chinese Martial Arts Articles
Supporting Members MAP Shop Banned User List Terms of Service

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #46  
Old 16-Apr-2017, 04:27 PM
wonglongwingchu's Avatar
wonglongwingchu wonglongwingchu is offline
Valued Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2017
Location: Anaheim, CA
Posts: 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chadderz View Post
I can see your point. Although chi Sao continually goes back to a point of nutrality and sensetivity. I would say it's a lot closer to wrestling-style pummelling.

https://youtu.be/1fz-duVr-vY
Good point. we do reset a lot more. Probably depends on each school too. Ours basically is close range sparring from the chi sao position.

I guess it is a bit of a stretch to compare it directly to rolling. More like when boxers work in the pocket and try to improve close range skills.
Reply With Quote
  #47  
Old 16-Apr-2017, 06:40 PM
icefield's Avatar
icefield icefield is offline
Valued Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: midlands
Posts: 2,919
Quote:
Originally Posted by wonglongwingchu View Post
Good point. we do reset a lot more. Probably depends on each school too. Ours basically is close range sparring from the chi sao position.

I guess it is a bit of a stretch to compare it directly to rolling. More like when boxers work in the pocket and try to improve close range skills.
But both boxing and rolling involve using exactly the same techniques as you would use in a fight from positions you would actually see in a fight, chi sao seems to start from an artificial situation, use positions you dont see in a fight, it's also extremely easy to see the attributes rolling and training in the pocket build, most can't seem to agree on what attributes chi sao is actually developing or what it's usefulness is
Reply With Quote
  #48  
Old 16-Apr-2017, 08:15 PM
wonglongwingchu's Avatar
wonglongwingchu wonglongwingchu is offline
Valued Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2017
Location: Anaheim, CA
Posts: 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by icefield View Post
But both boxing and rolling involve using exactly the same techniques as you would use in a fight from positions you would actually see in a fight, chi sao seems to start from an artificial situation, use positions you dont see in a fight, it's also extremely easy to see the attributes rolling and training in the pocket build, most can't seem to agree on what attributes chi sao is actually developing or what it's usefulness is
I personally disagree with that. Most if not all of the moves in chi sao, are exactly what we would use in a real fight. And if you are doing chi sao as it was meant to and learning all of the moves you need to, it will give you a lot of edge when it comes to close range fighting. In fact, without it, it'd be hard to actually use wing chun at all.

Just from my own experience.
Reply With Quote
  #49  
Old 16-Apr-2017, 09:55 PM
SWC Sifu Ben's Avatar
SWC Sifu Ben SWC Sifu Ben is offline
I am the law
 
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: Toronto, Canada
Posts: 1,727
Quote:
Originally Posted by wonglongwingchu View Post
I personally disagree with that. Most if not all of the moves in chi sao, are exactly what we would use in a real fight.
That's really not true though. The techniques in chi sao are set up to work from a certain range with continuous pressure. They will work within specific contexts. "Real fight" is essentially meaningless though and you could be trying to mean everything from a legal use of force engagement from a variety of ranges to a social-violence conflict. Either way, chi sao misses out on a lot, and there's a lot contextually within the artificial construct of chi sao which is present and not reflective of actual conflict, or which is absent and not reflective of actual conflict.

Don't get me wrong, there's lots that's useful in there, and especially within certain contexts, but chi sao is an artificial isolation of a specific range to drill specific kinds of attributes and techniques and it's not exactly the way it would be used in a lot of scenarios. It's a drill which which needs to be advanced from and incorporated into the rest of the skillset.
__________________
Sifu Ben
http://soaringwingchun.com

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dean Winchester View Post
Personally I just strip naked cover myself in bacon fat and run outside shouting "dinner is on me baby!".
Reply With Quote
  #50  
Old 16-Apr-2017, 10:15 PM
wonglongwingchu's Avatar
wonglongwingchu wonglongwingchu is offline
Valued Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2017
Location: Anaheim, CA
Posts: 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by SWC Sifu Ben View Post
That's really not true though. The techniques in chi sao are set up to work from a certain range with continuous pressure. They will work within specific contexts. "Real fight" is essentially meaningless though and you could be trying to mean everything from a legal use of force engagement from a variety of ranges to a social-violence conflict. Either way, chi sao misses out on a lot, and there's a lot contextually within the artificial construct of chi sao which is present and not reflective of actual conflict, or which is absent and not reflective of actual conflict.

Don't get me wrong, there's lots that's useful in there, and especially within certain contexts, but chi sao is an artificial isolation of a specific range to drill specific kinds of attributes and techniques and it's not exactly the way it would be used in a lot of scenarios. It's a drill which which needs to be advanced from and incorporated into the rest of the skillset.
Yeah, I agree that it certainly is set up to work from a certain range and strategy. Which is what you are supposed to implement and carry out in a fight.

I'm simply arguing that it's very similar to practicing boxing inside the pocket. Didn't mean "real fight" to cover all aspects of fighting.

I agree it is an artificial isolation to drill and develop techniques. All i'm saying is that when you do enter that specific range and context, the techniques would be the same in the real and simulated situation. For me, it doesn't matter if we started sparring or fighting from farther away, once we get into a medium/close range, my techniques from chi sao comes out.
Reply With Quote
  #51  
Old 17-Apr-2017, 01:25 AM
SWC Sifu Ben's Avatar
SWC Sifu Ben SWC Sifu Ben is offline
I am the law
 
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: Toronto, Canada
Posts: 1,727
Quote:
Originally Posted by wonglongwingchu View Post
Yeah, I agree that it certainly is set up to work from a certain range and strategy. Which is what you are supposed to implement and carry out in a fight.
No plan survives contact with the enemy

Quote:
Originally Posted by wonglongwingchu View Post
I'm simply arguing that it's very similar to practicing boxing inside the pocket. Didn't mean "real fight" to cover all aspects of fighting.

I agree it is an artificial isolation to drill and develop techniques. All i'm saying is that when you do enter that specific range and context, the techniques would be the same in the real and simulated situation. For me, it doesn't matter if we started sparring or fighting from farther away, once we get into a medium/close range, my techniques from chi sao comes out.
Except it's not. Because chi sao isn't to any high degree of contact, and can't be without a great deal of protection, the low level of feedback incentivizes speed above all else and can develop bad habits.

And on top of that the techniques won't be the same because most people whether trained or untrained don't fight like chunners. People don't punch like chunners, people don't want to bridge like chunners, and even at that range you're not going to encounter the same kind and proportion of angles of pressure and type of attacks you'll face from chunners. You develop insular habits. When's the last time someone grabbed you by the shirt in chi sao and just started punching around your guard and you had to recover from being clocked repeatedly like that? I'm going to guess never because it violates the economy of motion both chunners strive for, but violation of the range you can maintain in chi sao is something you will encounter a lot if you engage in social violence, as are things like needing to escape from the clinch, deal with grabs, shoves, etc. So there's a LOT in chi sao which isn't covered for both social and a-social violence.

Chi sao teaches some skills you have to bridge into sparring and other forms of pressured training/testing, but it's not the same as actually fighting at that range, it certainly doesn't include everything, and it's VERY overvalued by most chunners.
__________________
Sifu Ben
http://soaringwingchun.com

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dean Winchester View Post
Personally I just strip naked cover myself in bacon fat and run outside shouting "dinner is on me baby!".
Reply With Quote
  #52  
Old 17-Apr-2017, 01:45 AM
wonglongwingchu's Avatar
wonglongwingchu wonglongwingchu is offline
Valued Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2017
Location: Anaheim, CA
Posts: 42
I'm simply saying it covers a sizable amount of close quarter combat and develops good techniques for attacking, blocking, and dealing with pressure.

I agree it's overvalued by some chunners, but at the same time it's still one of the most important aspect. Without it, I doubt you can apply wing chun or learn wing chun at the pace of the people who does chi sao. At the same time of course there are needs for clinching practice, practice against hooks and round attacks, against round kicks, etc. But that doesn't mean chi sao is useless or the techniques learned doesn't apply in a lot of the situations.

All i'm saying is that it's not useless. Or that the techniques doesn't carry over at all. Because it does. When I said that "Most if not all of the moves in chi sao, are exactly what we would use in a real fight. " I really mean that the techniques is the same if the circumstance is the same. I'm not at all saying chi sao will cover all of your bases.
__________________
Sifu Richard

“Life repeats itself mindlessly – unless you become mindful, it will go on repeating like a wheel.”
― Osho

http://wingchunanaheim.com/
Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



All times are GMT. The time now is 03:31 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.