Martial Arts Planet  


Go Back   Martial Arts Planet > Styles > Kung Fu
Arcade Journals Banned User List

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1  
Old 18-Feb-2007, 05:55 PM
WotEvaYuKanDo's Avatar
WotEvaYuKanDo WotEvaYuKanDo is offline
Valued Member
 

Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 185
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Lau Gar - Some Historical Material Of Interest(1)

I have enjoyed reading the various Lau Gar threads. Apologies for starting another one but here is something hopefully sufficiently fresh (as far as this forum goes) to stimulate further thought and discussion. I was able this weekend to fish out a couple of old combat magazines which had Lau articles that had stuck in my head. I've scanned them and fixed up the character-recognition errors.

The material below is from a 1995 article by Tony Leung who ran a column called 'Roots of Kung Fu'

Enjoy

Quote:
In Southern China, the five most popular and well known martial systems practised are HUNG-KAR (HON-JIA in Mandarin), LAU-KAR (LIU-JIA), CHOI KAR (CAI-JIA), LEE-KAR (LI-JIA) and MOK-KAR (MO-JIA). In this article we are looking into the historical and training background of LAU-KAR QUAN, the second biggest family system practised in the south of China.

This system flourishes around the areas of QinZhou, LeiZhou, LianZhou and GaoZhou etc. There are differing accounts of who might be the founder of this system. One source claims the style, was founded by Liu QingShan. However, the most commonly accepted version is that it was founded by Liu Sheng of the Qing Emperor QianLon period (CE 1736). Liu was also known as Liu SanYan (Three Eyes) because of an eye-like scar between his two eyes.

Liu might have been a native of XiaSiFu QuangDong province or from a village of the ZhanJiang area. He was a hunter by trade and it is said that during one of his many tiger-hunting ventures, he was attacked and seriously injured by a large tigress. A travelling monk happened to hear Liu's desperate cries and came to the rescue, driving off the tigress and saving Liu from being mauled. The monk carried the badly injured Liu to his home and nursed him back to health with herbal medicines.

It was almost. three months before Liu was back on his feet again. As soon as he regained his strength, he begged the monk to teach him the skills of fighting so he could fend off any further assaults from wild animals or bandits. Finally the monk agreed to teach Liu
his martial arts. Through being ahunter, Liu already had knowledge offighting skills, so he was able to learn quickly. He discovered that the monk's name was ZhiShan and his martial art was of ShaoLin origin. The monk instructed Liu to distinguish his own
practice by naming it after himself. For this reason, Liu named the system Liu-Jia-Quan, meaning 'Liu's family fighting methods'. Liu ShanYan taught hisskills to Liu YuanJin, who in turn was succeeded by Liu BaoShan, Liu ZhaoGuang, Yan ChuMian, etc.

There are very many practitioners of Liu-Jia-Quan in southern China and the following material is extracted from a record of recent successors.

Liu ZhaoGuang, a KeJia man, was born around 1895 and is thought to be from XiangJiaoTang village, BuJi, in BaoAn county. He began training from an early age under Liu BaoShan. In 1930, Liu embarked on a business venture, left his village and went to work in Malaysia, where he, like other Overseas Chinese, was treated very unfairly. He regularly faced racial discrimination and even physical abuse.

One day, the Chinese-owned rubber plantation where Liu was working was suddenly invaded by a group of native Malaysians. They began to take rubber from the trees and needless to say, a fight broke out. The intruders were armed to the teeth and the Chinese workers suffered many casualties. Liu seized a plank of wood used for carrying baskets and dived into the machete swinging crowd. Using the plank and his knowledge of Liu-Jia-Guan (the family's pole fighting skills), Liu disarmed and badly injured most of the assailants.

The workers were amazed to learn that Liu was such a good Kung Fu fighter and thereafter, he taught some of fellow workers. Liu remained in Malaysia, until his return to Hong Kong in 1951, for a well-earned retirement. However, his retirement didn't quite materialise because news of his heroic exploits in Malaysia soon spread around the small KeJia community. Within months, Liu was teaching people from villages all around. One of his pupils was Yan ChuMian.

Yan ChuMian was born in Hong Kong during 1951. He is a native of WeiYang county, GuangDong province. Yan began training under Liu ZhaoGuang when he was about ten years old in the village of KengKou. He became one of the youngest but finest Liu-Jia-Quan practitioners in the local community. Another Liu-Jia-Quan teacher - Long JingLin - was sufficiently impressed by Yan to teach him his own interpretation of Liu-Jia-Quan. These two sets of experiences benefited Yan greatly and his skills quickly improved.

Eventually, Yan's hard training was rewarded when a village elder who was running some overseas Chinese restaurants, asked him to teach Liu-Jia-Quan in Belgium. Yan wasted no time, founding his FU-YING Chinese-martial arts association in 1975. He taught many students - both Chinese and non-Chinese and the following year, his efforts were recognised by the Hong Kong Chinese Martial Arts Association. Two fellow teachers, Long QiMing and Hu ShaoBao signed the letter of recommendation and Yan ChuMian was accepted as a 'SiFu'. He was also appointed as the Liu-Jia-Quan representative in Belgium. Yan taught and demonstrated Liu-Jia-Quan in Germany, Holland, France and other European countries before returning to Hong Kong in 1983.

According to SiFu Yan, the Liu-Jia-Quan training syllabus includes five training levels of unarmed combat. In the first level, juniors are taught the SI-MEN-WU-JIAN-QUAN which is the four directional and five angular dimensional form. This set shows beginners how to deal with four opponents and helps them develop good balance and agility.

Next, pupils are taught the SHUANG-FEI-HU-DEl-QUAN - the double butterfly palm form. Third level students learn the LIAN-HUAN-HU-BAO-QUAN, which is the tiger and leopard attacking form. Next to be learned is the FENG-CHE-JIAO-HOU-QUAN, or 'windmill rotating striking hands'. The fifth level form is TIAN-ZI-QUAN. In addition to the above, there are other training forms such as SHAO-YUN-TIAN (‘little cloudy sky'), SHI-QUAN ('ten sequences') and WU-XING-QUAN (the five animal forms).

SiFu Yan emphasises that each junior form comprises roughly eighty movements which function both offensively and defensively. He further points out that TIAN-ZI-QUAN is the most difficult because it requires the practitioner to manoeuvre within a 1 metre square floor pattern resembling the Chinese character ‘Tian’. Yan tells us that his teacher was very strict and made him get into the Tian floor pattern. Then he was obliged to leap, punch and kick but he was not allowed to step on any floor marks! If he did, his teacher would have hit him with a stick. Yan now admits that this sort of training helped him improve his balance and footwork. After working out on the Tian floor pattern, successful students are asked to perform all the forms on top of a square dining table!

Liu-Jia-Quan system contains many weapon training forms. These include WU-DIAN-MEI-HUA-GUN (the 'five point prune flower fighting pole form'), SHI-DIAN- SHUANG-TOU- GUN ('ten-point double-tipped pole form’), SHOU-LANG-GUN (‘the wolfs hand pole form’), ZHIN-YEN (‘the silver needle spear form), WU-LONG-CHU-DONG-BA ('five dragons leavingthe cave' tiger fork fighting form), QUING-LONG-RU-HAI-DAO ('the sea-diving green dragon' sabre form), SHI-MEN-JIAN (‘the four-directional double short sword form) and L1U-JIA-CHA-BA, the Liu family's tiger fork form.

Yan further records that there are many special training methods aimed at improving the reflexes and sensitivities of the practitioners. These methods are commonly known as DUI-CHUAN. The SAN-XING-CHUAN, or 'three stars forearm smashing method' is intended to condition students' forearms. Other methods are organised as sets of weapon sparring. SHUNG-GUN -DUI-CHAN is the pole contact fighting form, while YING-ZHEN-DUI-WAO-DENG are the spear vs sitting-bench exercises. DAO-DUI-BA are the sabre against tiger fork sets.

Liu-Jia-Quan is well known for the quality of its short range close-quarters combat. Fighters favour the use of the left-right attacking pattern and when faced with a head-on centre line attack, Liu-Jia practitioners use circular movements to absorb the assault. Then they make use of their five angular levels of attack. Sometimes, fighters use rather low stance work from which to launch low level attacks onto the opponent. The most commonly used stances are the SI-PING-MA (the horse stance), DIAO-MA (back, or cat stance). DI-MA (the low balancing stance) and LA-MA (withdrawing stance).

The above information comes from part of the syllabus covering the historical background of the second biggest Kung Fu 'family' system in Southern China. In order to promote genuine and traditional Liu-Jia-Quan, the China Cultural Fund is offering, two unique wall-charts illustrating an intermediate Liu-Jia-Quan training form, the WU-XING-QUAN (Five Animals). Technical information is supplied by teacher Zhao YongDe of the ZhongShan province.

The step-by-step, easy-to-learn wall charts include more than two hundred offensive and defensive techniques. Chart One (costs £4.80 incl p&p) covers history, background and three sections of the form. Chart Two (£6.80 incl p&p) shows the last two parts of the form. Both charts can be ordered from YUN-YE-TONG (address deleted –remember this is from 1995) YUN-YE-TONG plans to bring Yan ChuMin and his colleagues from Hong Kong for a weekend seminar/ workshop in London and Birmingham during Summer 1996.

Last edited by WotEvaYuKanDo; 18-Feb-2007 at 10:40 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 18-Feb-2007, 09:11 PM
Tartovski's Avatar
Tartovski Tartovski is offline
Valued Member
 

Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: On the edge
Age: 31
Posts: 1,983
Thanked 7 Times in 4 Posts
Do you have any references for that? Or where I could get hold of the original article?
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 18-Feb-2007, 09:22 PM
WotEvaYuKanDo's Avatar
WotEvaYuKanDo WotEvaYuKanDo is offline
Valued Member
 

Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 185
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Double checking I see it is the 1995 November issue of COMBAT magazine. I have it here, but it scanned well (COMBATs tend to disintigrate) I don't think there are any copying errors in the above extract concerning 'Lau Jia Quan' (the rest of the column went on to discuss the author's Hung Gar/Southern Mantis school's training programmes.)
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 18-Feb-2007, 09:44 PM
WotEvaYuKanDo's Avatar
WotEvaYuKanDo WotEvaYuKanDo is offline
Valued Member
 

Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 185
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Lau Gar - Some Historical Material Of Interest(2)

Here are some extracts from an intervirew with Jeremy Yau conducted in 1989 by Bey Logan for Combat magazine. The interview was quite lengthy, and I'm unsure if there would be issues of copyright were I to post all of it, so here are the highlights as I see them vis-a-vis the more 'interesting' discussions held on Lau Gar in other threads.

Quote:
BEY LOGAN: Jeremy, you are now, certainly, the most prominent figure in the U.K's kung fu community, and I’m sure a lot of our readers would be very interested to hear about your early years living in Hong Kong, and training in kung fu.

JEREMY YAU.: I started training in Hong Kong at the age of five. It was a family tradition. The training was very hard, and we started training every day at six o'clock in the evening, and finished at 10 o'clock. It was four hours every single day. No days off. You just trained, I don't think my childhood is a very enviable one for today's children. Every day was just going to school, eating, training and sleeping. We were not allowed to play, as such. We didn't have any toys. Our play was kung fu, and the only "toys" we had were the weapons we trained with.

B1.: And your instructor at that time was your grandfather, wasn't it?

JS.: That's right. After about six years training, when I was 11, I started to help out with the teaching of the beginners. Obviously, in the olden times, classes weren’t structured like they are now. The more advanced students helped the beginners, and they needed their own self-discipline in order to train. They were only to be corrected when necessary. It wasn't a class with people walking up and down in rows.

B1.: Where was the kwoon situated?.

J.Y.: It was in the village community centre in Kowloon City. It was a council building. My grandfather was also head of the village. It was slightly outside the Walled City, quite near the old Kai Tak airport location.

B1.: What was your family's situation at that time?

J.Y.: My father had died during the war, so I was more or less brought up by grandfather anyway. He was very well known for his Dit Dar (Chinese medicine) and also for other aspects of Chinese culture. Our family was reasonably well off, so we didn't need to depend upon any particular occupation in order to survive.

B1.: And the style was then called Lau Gar?

J..Y.: It has always been called Lau Gar.

B1.: What was the syllabus like in those days?

J.Y.: There were nine empty hands forms, and then there were all the different types of weapons. We started off with basics, stance and so on, and then would be taught the different sets. You wouldn't be taught another set until you'd mastered the one before. There wasn't a grading, as such, but at some time the Master would come and look at you and decide whether you were ready to learn the next set, and so on. All the time you were learning a set it would be broken down. These days we do hand blocks and kick blocks separately. In those days, we'd take them out of the set, and learn to use it as such. You'd try variations of that technique. That was the basic form of the training.


BL.: One point that's been raised is that there seems to be several different versions of Lau Gar, with yours being far and away the most popular. There seems to be a separate version on mainland China, another version in America. Can you explain this?

J.Y.: There have never been different Lau Gars. However, at least as far as the British version goes, there have been IMPROVEMENTS. For example, most kung fu techniques were originally designed as being right-handed, with most people being forced to use their right hands. I have done a few things that enable left-handed people to train, and that ensures that people train both sides of the body.

B.L.: I understand that the established Lau Gar in this country will, of necessity, have evolved over the years, but what I’m particularly interested is the route that Lau Gar took from Shaolin, seen as the birth-place of Chinese kung fu, to Hong Kong.

J.Y.: First, let me say that there are no DIFFERENT kinds of Lau Gar. What has happened is that, later, people have claimed that they are Lau Gar because it was one of the lesser known of the Shaolin styles. The practice of Lau Gar was restricted. It was only taught to a limited amount of people. Now, Lau Gar originated in Shaolin, obviously, but our specific founder was a man named Lau Sam Man, "Three-Eyed" Lau, from the
Kongsi Province. My grandfather actually went into China to learn it.When he came back to Hong Kong he found another master of Lau Gar, whom he served until the man died. Of the older generation, no-one would question our authenticity. The masters in Hong Kong knew my grandfather well, and none would deny his origin. However, today, with people in this country who are more commercially oriented, you hear them say “untraditional”, "unoriginal", “ungenuine", and other such slang terms.
Quote:
B.L.: I remember stories about your grandfather used to circulate through the Lau Gar community. There was one about his skill at Lion dancing...

J.Y.: We used to do the Kei Lun, which today people translate in England as the Unicorn dance, but KelLun is not Unicorn. It's mythic Chinese animal. It's not a horse with a horn, but that's probably the nearest thing in English. In this dance, you use big cymbals and a very small, high-pitched drum and. a big gong. Those were the three instruments.
The dance was a ritual to show respect and bring in luck on festive occasions.
Quote:
BL .:Was there a long gap between the time you left college in Hong Kong and when you came to England?
J.Y.: Yes. I used to teach English in the evenings at a night school, and I also worked as a storekeeper at the RAF station. I didn't do a lot of kung fu instruction, because, at that time in the 50's, there was a lot of trouble in Hong Kong. A lot of riots. My grandfather closed the school completely, without hesitation. He didn't want to teach people so they could go out and fight in the street. He just kept a few of his students training under him,
and I think that that was the stopping point for the style until I came over to this country

BL.: What brought about your move to this county?

J.Y.: I think it is the land of opportunity! My brother had come over before me. I arrived, I thought it looked very sad. I arrived in Birmingham in 1961, and I thought it looked
miserable. I was most disappointed. Then I started working, in the restaurant business, for my brother, and then, eventually, I started my own business.

B1, There's one aspect of the success.of Lau Gar that cannot be undervalued: You were already a .good businessman before you started to teach kung fu in this country. Were you trained in business, or were you naturally, good at it?

J.Y.: I did study a little bit. When I arrived in this country, I realised that there was no point in complaining about it. You had to adjust to your circumstances. Catering seemed to be the main outlet for business for the Chinese at that time, so I took a course in catering management which taught me a few things which might have helped. Having said that, my family in Hong Kong had always been in business, so I had that background.
Quote:
B.L.: While building up your restaurant business, did you still find time to maintain the practice of your kung fu privately?

J.Y.: Yes. I did my own training with a few friends who were interested in learning kung fu. Bernard Chong was one of them. He, of course, went onto become one of my instructors when Lau Gar was established in this country. It's funny, but when I first started working in England, I was not a very popular employee, because everywhere I went I took all my equipment, my weights and weapons. I didn't have anywhere to train, so, if the restaurant closed in the afternoon, then I'd be training in there.
Quote:
B.L.: At the time that you met Mike Haig, he already had a functioning martial arts establishment at Temple Passage. I believe there was a man named Pat Carroll teaching there, who had trained in Wado Ryu and a little Wing Chun ... What kind of situation did you inherit?

J.Y.: I wouldn't say I inherited it, as such. When Mike was introduced to me and asked me to teach for him, my first impression of him was not too good! He was young and he looked quite flamboyant. I didn't think that anyone his age who looked as he did could have any genuine interest in martial arts. I had no involvement with other kinds of martial arts, so I didn't know that he was such a big name in the karate world at that time. Initially, it didn't interest me very much, and I was very sceptical.

BL.: What changed your mind?

J.Y.: I went in with an open mind and started teaching a few of the instructors, the karate people who were down there already. I wasn't interested in what had been taught there before. When I arrived, I made it clear that it was going to be my way or no way!

BL.: It seems to me that we're dealing with two different entities: Lau Gar as it existed in a small, select group under your grandfather in Hong Kong, and the Lau Gar organisation that has developed in this country. One question that I’d realty appreciate your answering for me, because I hear it so often and don't know the answer is this: Why is the second form of Lau Gar almost identical to the first form of Wing Chun?

J.Y.: Okay. As a sometime Wing Chun man yourself, can you answer my question: Where does Wing Chun come from?

BL.: In recorded H1STORY, it comes from Fatshan. In legend, it originates with Ng Mui a nun at the Shaolin temple in Hunan.

J.Y.: So why is it so remarkable to find that Lau Gar and Wing Chun, which are both descended from Shaolin, , should have some similarities?

B.L.: It just seems unusual that there are so few similarities between the styles OTHER than that form. The first form, of Wing Chun is part of a comprehensive attitude towards martial art, while the nature of Lau Gar, as a whole, seems very different from that.

J.Y.: Then again, Shaolin is such a big collection of groups of martial arts. Each monk, once he had done basic training and accomplished some deeds, would be awarded a certain technique from the seniors. Therefore, you could go to one group and be awarded one of their techniques.
B.L.: So you're telling me that it is definitely not the case that that form was introduced AFTER Lau Gar came to England?

J.Y.: That's right. People can find similarities wherever they look for them. I'll never criticise any martial art, but its true that the punching in karate, taekwondo and kung fu looks very similar. This is because a punch is a punch! Different masters might develop slight differences in different styles, and so the punch LOOKS like the punch from another style, but the way of USING it is very different. The way of generating its power may be totally different. Wing Chun’s punch, as I’m sure you know, is performed in an upright position. Ours, to start with, anyway, sideways.
Quote:
B L.: I understand that, quite recently, you've introduced a Tiger and Crane form into the Lau Gar syllabus...

J.Y.: No, that's not quite true. What has happened is that one of my senior students, John Russell, has learnt the Tiger and Crane form, with my blessing, from someone else. He has actually learned of five different variations on the form. Every time, he comes back and shows me the different versions he's learned. I said to him that I felt it was a bit tedious to remember five different versions of the same form, and so I helped him tidy it up, and put five together, making a new form for him to practice. This was just out of pure interest, for pure knowledge. Yes, there are a few other students who have learnt it, but its not part of the offcial Lau Gar syllabus. Its just the sharing of knowledge for the SAKE of sharing knowledge.
Quote:
B.L.: Have there been any major changes to the Lau Gar syllabus over
the years, and, if so, what has brought them about?

J.Y.: Okay, let me give you an example. A long time ago, as I told you earlier, before I developed Lau Gar in this country I'd already instructed a few friends privately, and one of them later became one of my instructors. At that time, he wasn't absolutely certain about the' syllabus, so he was teaching a totally different form within it. The form,got introduced in this manner, and then stayed stuck in there for a couple of years! It was a Pak Mei form, but I had to leave it in there at that time, until the time was right to pull it out. I don't think that its right for us to have a form from an outside style as part of our syllabus.

B.L.: Have there been any example of you modifying the forms, to suit the generally bigger build of westerners?

J.Y.: No. I don't think that’s necessary. The build will adapt to the form and the form to the build. It’s the same in Tai Chi. If you're young, you do a low form, middle-aged, a medium, height form and if you're very old, a very high form. The form actually adapts itself to what you are capable of doing so there's actually no need to change the form.

BL.: One change you have made, though, is that you've taken out the blocks and strikes from the form whereas previously it was up to the student to do that for himself.

J.Y.: That's right.

Last edited by WotEvaYuKanDo; 18-Feb-2007 at 10:55 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 18-Feb-2007, 10:28 PM
butcher wing's Avatar
butcher wing butcher wing is offline
Oi, Fatso!
 

Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Sunny West Midlands
Age: 41
Posts: 382
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
re:

Very interesting reading!!
__________________
"yat daam, yee lek, saam kung fu"
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 07:28 AM
CFT's Avatar
CFT CFT is offline
Valued Member
 

Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: UK
Posts: 708
Thanked 8 Times in 7 Posts
Quote:
Liu ZhaoGuang, a KeJia man, was born around 1895 and is thought to be from XiangJiaoTang village, BuJi, in BaoAn county.

<edit>

Liu remained in Malaysia, until his return to Hong Kong in 1951, for a well-earned retirement. However, his retirement didn't quite materialise because news of his heroic exploits in Malaysia soon spread around the small KeJia community. Within months, Liu was teaching people from villages all around. One of his pupils was Yan ChuMian.
KeJia = Hakka
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:24 AM
oldman oldman is offline
Banned
 

Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: My foot your face
Age: 42
Posts: 448
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by butcher wing
Very interesting reading!!

ditto
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:29 AM
oldman oldman is offline
Banned
 

Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: My foot your face
Age: 42
Posts: 448
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by CFT
KeJia = Hakka

here we go again
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:30 AM
Su lin Su lin is offline
Gone away
 

Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 15,881
Thanked 42 Times in 32 Posts
Erm,I think he is simply pointing it out for people who may not know what it means
__________________
My MAP journal: http://www.martialartsplanet.com/for...owjournal&j=15
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:33 AM
Mei Hua's Avatar
Mei Hua Mei Hua is offline
Banned
 

Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Minneapolis
Age: 32
Posts: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Shouldn't there just be a Lau Gar forum so that there can actually be some intelligent discussions in the KF forum?
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:35 AM
Su lin Su lin is offline
Gone away
 

Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 15,881
Thanked 42 Times in 32 Posts
Most of us try and conduct intelligent conversations about Lau.Maybe the two posts of historical interests could be merged,not sure there needs to be two threads as could confuse matters?

There was a thread a while back about Lau Gar origins so maybe it could be tidied up a bit?
__________________
My MAP journal: http://www.martialartsplanet.com/for...owjournal&j=15
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:37 AM
Mei Hua's Avatar
Mei Hua Mei Hua is offline
Banned
 

Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Minneapolis
Age: 32
Posts: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by Su Lin
Most of us try and conduct intelligent conversations about Lau.
Unfortunately, IME you're the only one I've seen that from, that says something.
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:37 AM
Bassmonkey's Avatar
Bassmonkey Bassmonkey is offline
Formerly Cobalt60
 

Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Bournemouth, United Kingdom
Age: 28
Posts: 569
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
It might actually be an idea to have a Lau Gar forum, there are always so many threads about it that it would probably warrant one.

Im certainly not complaining being a Lau Gar practioner myself, but I can see how it could get a bit frustrating for the non lau gar peoples.

Oh and CFT, thanks for the translation as i didnt know what keJia meant.

Mei Hua - Have you emailed the mods your request?

I hope that these articles will bring some.....closure.... to the lau gar threads that are often bandied about. The first article after all has alot of info on lineage and hopfully isnt just hearsay and conjecture.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 09:41 AM
Su lin Su lin is offline
Gone away
 

Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 15,881
Thanked 42 Times in 32 Posts
It doesn't need its own forum.

There is lots of discussion about it as it is a very popular style over here in the UK and lots of things to discuss.Maybe if people just thought about it first before creating new threads to see if they are required or not?

I just think merging is the answer in this case.

Lau doesn't warrant its' own forum.

And thanks Mei!
__________________
My MAP journal: http://www.martialartsplanet.com/for...owjournal&j=15
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 19-Feb-2007, 10:07 AM
Cathain's Avatar
Cathain Cathain is offline
Lily Lau Gar
 

Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Scotland
Age: 31
Posts: 830
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Excellent stuff. Anymore of these?
Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Historical Evidence on the Resurection of Jesus TheMightyMcClaw Religion 72 22-Jun-2007 06:11 PM
Chin Woo School, historical question... KuKulzA Kung Fu 5 18-Oct-2006 02:08 AM
Historical Armor pest Ninjutsu 7 08-Apr-2006 10:42 AM
Would there be any interest in... TheDarkJester Kung Fu 14 17-Jan-2006 06:42 PM
Just out of interest leo MMA / Submission Fighting 13 27-Apr-2005 08:43 PM


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:35 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.