nzric
26-Oct-2004, 11:20 PM
I thought of this idea from another current thread - about how postures and stances can probably correlate to building architecture. It's a lot easier to see the principles when we use physical examples.
Before someone points out that stances (esp. in tai chi) are always dynamic, I just want to say it's a metaphor. Ok, just a metaphor!! :D Oh, and I'm not an architect so I'm probably getting a lot of it wrong :cool:
Tai chi bow stance/Tree Hugging/Three Circle posture: Gothic cathedral.
Tall, upright stance where the intent is directed 'upward' through a straight load-bearing core (spine). While gothic cathedrals have flying buttresses to stabilise the centre against sideways force, the tai chi stance has the feet directed inward and circular arms to widen the balance.
Horse Stance/Chen style stance (? that'll annoy you chennies :)): Pyramid/Steeple
Force directed diagonally down to create a solid, stable base. While a Karate stance is a Pyramid of Giza, the chen stance is probably more of an Eiffel Tower type structure because the silk reeling ability creates a lighter, more free upper half while retaining the base.
Capoeira footwork/stance: Uneven pyramid/bellcurve/burial mound
Force is directed outward at a low angle, while the whole structure remains low. Any flexibility/movement tends to come from the extremities, rather than in the chen-type posture.
Boxer stance: Skyscraper
Force is directed downward (e.g. boxer footwork e.g. to maintain the downward force) rather than laterally. This changes (i.e. back foot used as a brace to the structure when punching/defending) but main intent is to keep force directed down.
Any ideas on the bagua stance or certain tai chi moves??
Before someone points out that stances (esp. in tai chi) are always dynamic, I just want to say it's a metaphor. Ok, just a metaphor!! :D Oh, and I'm not an architect so I'm probably getting a lot of it wrong :cool:
Tai chi bow stance/Tree Hugging/Three Circle posture: Gothic cathedral.
Tall, upright stance where the intent is directed 'upward' through a straight load-bearing core (spine). While gothic cathedrals have flying buttresses to stabilise the centre against sideways force, the tai chi stance has the feet directed inward and circular arms to widen the balance.
Horse Stance/Chen style stance (? that'll annoy you chennies :)): Pyramid/Steeple
Force directed diagonally down to create a solid, stable base. While a Karate stance is a Pyramid of Giza, the chen stance is probably more of an Eiffel Tower type structure because the silk reeling ability creates a lighter, more free upper half while retaining the base.
Capoeira footwork/stance: Uneven pyramid/bellcurve/burial mound
Force is directed outward at a low angle, while the whole structure remains low. Any flexibility/movement tends to come from the extremities, rather than in the chen-type posture.
Boxer stance: Skyscraper
Force is directed downward (e.g. boxer footwork e.g. to maintain the downward force) rather than laterally. This changes (i.e. back foot used as a brace to the structure when punching/defending) but main intent is to keep force directed down.
Any ideas on the bagua stance or certain tai chi moves??