PDA

View Full Version : Training, Diet and...Blood Type?


YODA
20-Dec-2002, 06:17 PM
Here's an interesting article I came across in my cyber-travels :D

Training, Diet and...Blood Type?
by Mark Ginther

Those who wish to lose weight or improve their health are often confused by the dozens, if not hundreds of diets to choose from. High carbohydrates-low fat, and high protein-low carbohydrates represent the extreme opposites of the popular diet spectrum. Why is it that one person will lose weight and feel better on a particular diet, while another suffers horribly on the very same diet? And how can one know which diet will work best for oneself?

Dr. Peter J. D' Adamo may have the answer. In his book Eat Right for Your Type; he details the evolutionary origins of blood type, the changes in environment that influenced them, and the physiological differences between the blood types that resulted.Type-O, the original blood type, was the predominate blood type of the early hunter-gatherers. Type-A later gained prominence when agriculture began to replace hunting as the primary means of food acquisition. With later environmental changes Type-B developed, and as groups of A and B began to intermingle, AB emerged. Biochemistry adapted to meet these environmental changes. Thus, for example, Type-Os do better on a high animal protein/low carbohydrate diet, and Type-As the opposite. This can be demonstrated physiologically as Os have a high acid content in their stomachs, necessary for digesting meat, and Type-A's stomachs have a high alkaline content, necessary for digesting grain.

In his next book, Live Right for Your Type, he goes into greater detail, explaining how these physiological differences go beyond diet and can profoundly influence the way we will respond to the stresses of our environment.

For example: blood type A (then B) are the most prone to be cortisol (a catabolic hormone that breaks down amino acids from the muscles and converts them into glucose for energy) resistant and tend to have the highest rise in cortisol with stress. They also tend to have the most problems with lowering cortisol levels to normal following stress. Cortisol has anti-inflammatory properties, and is necessary for life, but when chronically elevated can cause lethargy, illness, and even loss of muscle.

This is critical for exercise prescription, and suggests that Type-As are more prone to overtraining, and need to take a slower, more moderate approach when beginning an exercise program.

Also interesting, and significant:

The blood type response to stress greatly influences thyroid hormone function on the cellular level. Proper thyroid levels are critical for maintaining normal bodyfat levels.

Types A and AB are the only types that can do well on strict vegan diets.

Lectinsdiverse protein structures found in many common foodscan have specific interactions with cells, tissues and the immune system depending on blood type.

Below is a brief overview of D'Adamo's recommendations:

Type-O: Emphasize animal proteins; focus on anger management; engage in vigorous exercise; control impulsive behavior.

Type-A: Emphasize vegetables; concentrate on stress management; engage in gentle exercise to reduce stress; take naps or frequent breaks to stay focused.

Type-B: Vary your diet; focus on creative outlets, engage in meditation to reduce stress; avoid emotional overreaction.

Type-AB: Eat smaller, more frequent meals; focus on cultivating your spiritual tendencies; break up your day physical activity to feel more energized; avoid feelings of isolation.

Admittedly, this all does sound a bit like alchemy, and much of his evidence is anecdotal, however Dr. D'Adamo does make a convincing case, particularly in his second book which notes several new medical studies that give support to his theories and recommendations.

Mark
25-Dec-2002, 05:44 AM
A friend of mine asked her doctor about the blood type diet. He/she said it only works if your type A. I'm a type O and I ate only meats and no carbs for a week or too, not a long time, but It didn't effect me either way. I just figured I'd be better off eating everything in moderation and regular exercise. That's the best way IMHO.

Mark

Saz
25-Dec-2002, 06:49 PM
http://www.wholisticresearch.com/info/artshow.php3?artid=70

r4bid
26-Dec-2002, 08:14 PM
It sounds extreamly cool and makes sense I guess but it would seem that not everyone is so sure

http://www.vegsource.com/klaper/diet.htm

fluffydoc
29-Dec-2002, 02:52 PM
Originally posted by YODA

Below is a brief overview of D'Adamo's recommendations:

Type-O: Emphasize animal proteins; focus on anger management; engage in vigorous exercise; control impulsive behavior.

Type-A: Emphasize vegetables; concentrate on stress management; engage in gentle exercise to reduce stress; take naps or frequent breaks to stay focused.

Type-B: Vary your diet; focus on creative outlets, engage in meditation to reduce stress; avoid emotional overreaction.

Type-AB: Eat smaller, more frequent meals; focus on cultivating your spiritual tendencies; break up your day physical activity to feel more energized; avoid feelings of isolation.



Breaking people down into 4 groups with similar biochemistry, personality, need for company, ability to tolerate stress etc. in this manner is about as scientific as astrology.

Humans are enormously diverse in their genetic make up - although trends occur, splitting everyone in just 4 groups is ridiculous. Also, it takes no account of the effect environment and upbringing has on an individual's ability to cope with stress/ control impulsive behaviours/ deal with anger etc. and I see no realationship between being AB and needing to "cultivate spiritual tendencies".

Also, just because something quotes recent medical studies which back up its claims, it doesn't mean (a) that the study was of good quality or (b) that its findings can be extrapolated to the claims being made.

I think this guy's just trying to make money out of people by taking a few facts and linking them together with pseudo-scientific nonsense that sounds good until you delve into it.

YODA
29-Dec-2002, 03:31 PM
I think this guy's just trying to make money out of people by taking a few facts and linking them together with pseudo-scientific nonsense that sounds good until you delve into it.

....... a growing trend these days.

Mark
30-Dec-2002, 02:26 AM
It's common to hear people say "I've tried all these diets, but they didn't work", but I get the feeling that most of them havent even thought about exercise.

Saz
30-Dec-2002, 04:48 AM
And a lot of people try diets, but to lose a decent amount of weight takes time. It can't be done in a few weeks.

Mark
30-Dec-2002, 09:45 PM
Yep, ever since I took it upon my self to exercise and get healthy about 2 or 3 years ago, I've only lost a little bit of weight. But I've gained strength, stamina, endurance, flexibility, self esteem, etc.

Ad McG
28-Feb-2004, 05:24 PM
and Type-A's stomachs have a high alkaline content, necessary for digesting grain.

What rubbish. All human stomachs contain hydrochloric acid. To me, it seems like the whole thing is a crock. I haven't looked into it, but how could blood type affect the way your body digested and used food?!?

Mika
29-Feb-2004, 08:31 AM
http://www.martialartsplanet.com/forums/showthread.php?t=10804

totality
29-Feb-2004, 05:59 PM
www.veloforce.net
mr. ginther's homepage. he does have some good articles on periodization, but...well, his article on weight training for mma is ridiculous.

MuayThaiGuy
29-Feb-2004, 07:41 PM
Add me to the "bollocks" camp. The part about having more alkaline in your stomach doesn't make sense. Your stomach has to be acidic, otherwise your digestive enzymes don't work. Any alkaline ions are going to be pretty much immediately turned to water by all the hydrochloric acid in there. Also, this guy hasn't done any actual studies to back up his theories. People who cherrypick others' research and are trying to sell you something should be viewed in the light of salesmen, not scientists. Finally, anecdotal evidence should never be used to support scientific arguments. It sheds far more light on the biases of whoever's using it, rather than the point they're trying to prove.

/skeptic mode off